Elijah attempted to track down Katerina, but failed. Elijah turned down Dominic's proposal and attacked him, holding him on the balcony in display of the whole party. They managed to wake Klaus up but Davina finished the spell on him, breaking his sireline. He was forced to see that he had actually killed her due to his bloodlust as a newly turned vampire. Season 2: After Hayley and Klaus had to give up their daughter to protect her, Elijah and Hayley become estranged. It is clear they feel an attraction towards each other, however due to other factors, do not act upon them. In From a Cradle to a Grave, Elijah bursts into the church looking for Hayley and screaming her name, he stops dead in his tracks, panting and out of breath as a result of the werewolf bites, and struggles to focus his vision. He shivers and groans in pain, and explains to Hayley she has to leave and that his mind is flooded with torturous memories. When Elijah questioned why Klaus spared Marcel even with a blade that could kill him, Klaus explained that killing Marcel would have given the Hollow what it wanted. Klaus daggered Elijah once they arrived at Alaric's apartment, but eventually Elijah was un-daggered by Damon Salvatore. Klaus tells Elijah that he chases his redemption like a man rolling a stone up a mountain. Klaus, not wanting to hear some newly discovered secret, brushed him off saying it could wait. Elijah explained that numerous massacres of werewolf packs had been happening nearby, but Klaus thought the purging was too systematic for Mikael. Freya tells Elijah and Rebekah that she put a spell Klaus' paintings. He witnesses Jackson and Hope meeting each other for the first time. Back at the mansion, Elijah is reunited with his younger sisters and Hayley. He even mentioned that for the thousand years the he has lived, he has only been in love twice. Later, Hayley told him about her plan to marry Jackson in a ritual that would give their pack hybrid-like abilities. Elijah tries to calm down Marcel and tells him, he doesn't like to either but tells him that Davina will die either way. As soon as Klaus shows up Elijah is ready to attack him. Elijah and Thomas work together to find Hayley. Elijah swore that if Marcel continued to get in the way of his little brother's redemption, he would deliver on him another kind of nightmare. Antoinette explained the ins and outs of being a vampire, and he told her how he didn't remember anything about who he was and the farthest back he could remember was that he just woke up starving on a bus six days prior, with nothing but a vague memory of a man, his daylight ring, cufflinks with the letter E engraved on them, and a mysterious note that said "don't look back". She tells him that Dahlia won't be able to hurt Hope or any child again. He ordered a wolf hunt as a peace offering to Marcel's crew. Elijah tries to help his siblings in Long Way Back from Hell. In Always and Forever, Elijah is seen talking with the bartender, Camille, about his half-brother. Hayley knocks Genevieve down and runs toward the baby, but Genevieve casts a pain infliction spell on Hayley, which makes her fall onto her knees. Elijah advised Marcel to execute Shen Min immediately since letting him live could mean their deaths but Hayley was planning on interrogating him. Their love. Though Hope thought it was her subconscious, Elijah knew it was true, since he had indeed promised her a dance. Sophie then explains how it is possible that Hayley is having his child, since vampires cannot procreate. She admitted that she knew he was an Original Vampire and that his family was legendary, and had enemies everywhere, not wanting to say anything so he wouldn't be in danger. After the party, when Vincent spoke with Elijah about the show he put on, Elijah reminded him that an alliance between he and Vincent was essential in stopping the Hollow. Elijah tells Hayley to marry Jackson but then pulls her close and starts to kiss her. In What, Will, I, Have, Left, Elijah and Antoinette were visited by Antoinette's "mother", Greta Sienna. It's just, most people die before the list gets embarrassing. He wants it to go away. Sometime later Elijah meets Freya at St. Louis Cathedral. Elijah tried to convince her to stop with her kill list since it would start a war and implored her to think about Hope's safety. Elijah initially wanted Klaus to go as Hope needed her father but Klaus didn't trust Elijah to be left with their brothers. In A Closer Walk With Thee, Elijah is seen with Klaus at Father Kieran's wake where people are drinking to celebrate his life rather than mourn. Hayley appears and tells Elijah that she will take care of Serena but to also be strong. And tells her, he will not have her pay that price, but Hayley wants to stay. When The Strix held a meeting to discuss the future of their organization and the weapon that could possibly kill Elijah, the group's sire arrived and Elijah made it clear that despite the power vacuum Tristan left, Aya couldn't just ascend to leadership.